I decided that I no longer wanted to be on FreshDirect's mailing list. So when I got this (Feb 15) email from them, I clicked the "unsubscribe" link at the bottom of the page. (The link is to http://ebm.cheetahmail.com/r/webunsub?t=hBLeq0YB7S$bRB7WmhsCkNn-eUR&email=nickelsanddimes@gmail.com&n=1). My email client is not mangling the link. It's taking me to it exactly as it should.)

Which took me to this page. On which I clicked the button.

Which generated this error.

So I went back to the original email and clicked the "contact us" link.

I sent them this letter. (Feb 15)

I got this reply. (Feb 15)

Which is why I'm surprised that today (Feb 16) I received this email.

The unsubscribe link at the bottom takes me back to the one-button page.

Which still generates this error.